ETERNALLY Thankful for the closet changes and the attic. I collect all the exploration clothes to make it easier to find other items, but they take up a lot of room I don't want.
Find it kind of a cheap move to make only one slot to save an outfit and force payment for others.
Like a Fashionista I can save unlimited outfit combinations from the getgo. This doesn't seem like a fair addition.

The market...I completely understand the reasoning behind it. And the deposit isn't bad. It costs 3 maana to sell for 100
It will also help clean the market out of those ridiculously high prices people put stuff for, and possibly force posters to put monthly reward items at affordable prices

The thing I ABSOLUTELY HATE??
The inability to "buy now" right when something is posted, and the inability to SEE the BIN price.
This will make trading impossible now, and make it extremely difficult to sell items to specific people. The difficulty it adds makes it not worth it in my opinion. I may as well close my store.

I wonder if they did this on purpose to stop people from making maana off of individual sales? To possibly force them to buy maana from the site?

---

Main Wishlist || Outfit Gallery

Play "Guardian Cosplay" Game
Play "What is Guardian Wearing?" Guessing Game

The attic was welcomed. I like the grouping of the items with different varations. The extra clicks can be a bit annoying though. Maybe they could've made it so that the items with only one variation can be accessed directly. Not that important though.

Well, the market.... is just a mess. I agree with @brokenendings that it'll make it clean up, but I still think that the deposit should be returned if the item isn't bought or the auction canceled, since so many of the items don't get bought.

The 1 hour wait is also pretty bad. They could've added a proper trading system to make it better but I guess not. I'm thinking of closing my store if nothing gets changed regarding this.

I have hopes that they'll make some changes but they're pretty low.

Last edited by Seff (04/22/2020 at 13:17)

---

Actually, if my information from the German site is correct, then the attic function isn't really that great.
If it isn't a software bug, then you will find the item you put in attic again on explorations - that way, you have the same item twice, in your wardrobe AND in the attic.

I was loving the changes until I saw: Immediate purchase available in [...] What. WHAT.

Did they just cancel trading altogether? Wishlists and stores canceled? Did they really have to do that?!

I wasn't bothered with the new deposit thing because I thought that it would make it easier to agree on a price when selling or trading items to players, as it won't just go up randomly, so at least that was nice. But now we can't do that?!

And it's also stupid that it is more expensive the more time you leave it there. The market is going to go dead this way! Some of us live in different timezones too, we would miss a lot of items if putting it up for a long time isn't encouraged!

I like that the closet is more organized, but this thing they did with the market is bs tbh. I was so happy with it but now... I'd rather not have anything changed.

Finally, the money-greediness reached the market! Great *sarcasm*

EDIT: They didn't even notify that about having to wait in the message, it's all like SURPRISE! Hilarious

Last edited by Vaihanai (04/22/2020 at 13:31)

---

Earendil wrote

Actually, if my information from the German site is correct, then the attic function isn't really that great.
If it isn't a software bug, then you will find the item you put in attic again on explorations - that way, you have the same item twice, in your wardrobe AND in the attic.

---

Main Wishlist || Outfit Gallery

Play "Guardian Cosplay" Game
Play "What is Guardian Wearing?" Guessing Game

That you can find the same piece of clothing twice is a bug, and they seem to have fixed it. There's an announcement over here:

https://www.eldarya.com/forum/t2291,1-attic-update.htm

Edit: Link fixed

Last edited by Maeris (04/22/2020 at 13:51)

So there's one curious thing about the market I can't figure out.
Every item you click on when you're deciding what to sell gives an automatic bid and BIN number, and it's different for every item you click on.

Like I clicked on a victoria hair and it put 210 bid price and 650 BIN price, but then I clicked on the naboo hair and it put 5 bid price and 15 BIN price. Where are these numbers coming from???

FIGURED IT OUT: It doesn't happen for EVERY item you click on. It only generates an auto bid and BIN IF the item is currently being sold on the market by someone.
So there's currently a Victoria hair on the market for BIN of 210, but idk where the 650 came from. There's also Naboo hair on the market for 5 bid and 15 BIN
but I clicked on desert night pants and didn't get an auto generated anything cuz there's none on the market

---

Main Wishlist || Outfit Gallery

Play "Guardian Cosplay" Game
Play "What is Guardian Wearing?" Guessing Game

I made the math for the deposits and found out the percentages for each time. It only depends on the inmediate purchase price:

  6h --> 1/17 --> 5.88%
12h --> 1/10 -->   10%
24h -->  1/8 --> 12.5%
48h -->  1/5 -->   20%

It's a lot higher than the 5% taxes of before.

Last edited by NoName_NoPower (04/22/2020 at 14:49)

I agree with the other comments - the deposit doesn't make sense.
Moreover it's not a deposit since the maanas you pay are not repaid if the auction is canceled or if the item is not sold. And the inability to "buy now" right when something is posted, and the inability to SEE the BIN price will make trading and saving up maanas impossible now. 
In my opinion this is another way to make players spend real money and I'm thinking of closing my account if nothing gets changed regarding this, like other players I've met on FR and IT servers. I don't have time and money to waste since things are getting worse on Eldarya.

I really hope that they will rethink this update and do a 180 degree turn.

Last edited by Idrin (04/22/2020 at 15:04)

Why on earth would you make us have to pay to sell things? The idea that someone would pay to then get rid of something is completely asinine.

Not surprised by Beemoov making the game worse suddenly, they must have thought it's been a while since they screwed us over~

---

Esstelle wrote

Will the deposit be returned if the item doesn't sell?

Last edited by Idrin (04/22/2020 at 15:05)

next update: if you want erika to breathe, pay 100 maanas.

---

Hey people there are more advantages than disadvantages. A complaint won’t change a thing. I find it a positive update.

---

how do u work this whole market system???????? I just ost 2800 manna because I got confused and now I'm broke... how do u work this thingggg help meeeeeeeee plzzzzzzzzzz I'm also selling a bindle for 2800 manna to replace it if anyone wants to buy plzzz do! I need that manna back 

went from 3134 manna to 162.... ouch

Last edited by azeralove (04/22/2020 at 17:20)

I'm not really a fan of anything in this update.
I personally like seeing all my items in all of their color variations in the closet. Kinda wish that it was optional to put all your color variations together in one slot, but I guess it's fine.

And in short, I hate the market thing...

---

Last edited by GrinningReaper (04/22/2020 at 17:52)

---

This market change is bad and nonsensical.

The in-universe reasoning is that we have to pay for the market space to sell the item, but with that logic there should be a set price depending on the length of the sale ONLY and the prices we choose shouldn't effect anything. Ugh.

This is frustrating - there are items I've kept from events years in the past that I haven't gotten around to selling. Now, I don't know if it will be worth the risk if no one buys them, even if I price them low. I just lose maana.

This "update" is a huge fail for me. Not being able to see all the color variations you have in your closet is annoying honestly (also to have to click through things even more). I find the attic option great but the rest is absolutely hideous, especially the market..I mean what's going on with that? It doesn't make any sense..

Nah sorry but this is such a bad change. I wonder where they got the idea for the market from? Nobody asked for this but we have so many other (actually good) suggestions which they don't care about..but well..let's destroy the market instead, that will for sure make players happier with the site xD

dangit.. what are you doing Beemoov

I'm not sure what to make of the new market yet, but I admit the new Closet function was a great idea. I've wanted an update of something like the 'attic' function for some time. It's SO nice to have. But like most players I am a little iffy about the market, I kinda hope there will be a follow up or some tweaks about it.

After all this time they made these small changes requested for years. Hope it continues like this, there is need for improvement.
I am really glad people can now save their outfits and hopefully the new feature on the market will help with the high prices and whatnot.

@brokenendings,... Very possible. This company is v greedy and crafty.

Edit; the whole market is a mess. Ir fks people up and over.

Last edited by Shintarou (04/22/2020 at 19:29)

---

margareze wrote

Hey people there are more advantages than disadvantages. A complaint won’t change a thing. I find it a positive update.

---

Nah man.

Take it all back and start over cause this ain't it. 

The closet organization is uncomfortable, but I can see how it's a positive, so no real complaints here on that. Paying for extra favorite outfit spots is a bit obnoxious, but if the prices were WAY LOWER, I'd have no real issues there.

The marketplace? No. That is a genuine mistake. The original system was fine. The only thing about it that needed work was a way to do direct user-to-user trading, and that has become even more of a problem with this 'update'. Add to it that posting anything for sale now guarantees a severe loss in funds if something is not sold in a given time-frame, and I must admit that I will be very surprised to see over 5 pages of items to be sold as a whole by the first week of May.

Perhaps, flaws and all, these new systems would be better received if you had, at least, given warning about the change. Unfortunately, much like a bad relationship, communication has continued to be lacking. You gave no warning for these changes, just like you gave no warning when you removed the monthly rewards, so the frustration people feel is heightened.

To solve all these issues, it might be wise to hold a sort of poll, or find a way to discuss options with the user-base directly, so that we might all have some sort of input, and can work together to find a system that works.

I love the attic idea very much so!! but i don't see how the "favorite outfit" idea is a very sufficient idea. if i have to pay to save more then one favorite outfit its not really useful for me to use. I understand the idea of why you added the market changes, but they really aren't that good AP is really hard to come by and a lot of players are now not selling things in the market. which means I'm not able to purchase my poor Pomponeige food at a lower price then what the store offers. which is probably not a bad thing to you, Beemoov, because i could always buy more AP. but thats the thing, i and many others don't have that sort of money to spend on mindless games. Thank you for reading my concerns. i hope you will take them into thought and consideration!  





P.S. (Please read all. Im sorry, i know it a lot)


This is totally off topic, and specifically for Beemov but if any of you (players) have advice I’d be happy to accept it.... here it goes, I'm on episode 7 (Im looking for Chrome’s companion) and my objective is to "Verifies Purrel’s Information" so I went to the burrow, I got a little trigger happy and clicked the dialogue really fast (don't judge, there was a lot of unneeded detail) I think I accidentally picked “Maybe I should dig the burrow”, instead of “I’ll look around, maybe I’ll find something there?” which leads to Valkons illustration (i found out later.) you would think that the episode would still go on nonetheless. But i've walked around everywhere on eldarya and i've even sent my companion out hoping maybe he would get chrome's companyoin, He found a bat looking companion but the bait used to catch it is 100 gold, and i don't have that kinda money! But I haven't gotten any dialogue or any new objective, nothing! And it's pretty frustrating! Beemoov and other players, Am i missing something? Do I have to look for something? Or is my game frozen? I'm so confused! I've researched every cheat sheet and watched every video and I've come up empty handed. Most videos and cheat sheets tell you to pick “Look Around” instead of “dig in the burrow” but they don't tell you what happens if you do click “dig the burrow.”

       
                                                 PLEASE HELP!!!!!

Last edited by felicityswan (04/26/2020 at 16:20)